BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
was driving by the chief around 8:15pm today (Sunday) and saw a helicopter doing a long line extraction from the base of the grand wall, just a little right of exasperator... not sure if this is connected to the above post, but wishing everybody well...
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Tue Apr 19, 2011 9:35 am
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
Very unfortunate. Not often you hear about this type of situation in Squamish. I heard the heli and thought it was a typical long weekend epic. Never would have thought it was anything overly serious.
Sorry to hear it. Really puts things in perspective.
Sorry to hear it. Really puts things in perspective.
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
Any info on specific nature of the accident (climbing or not climbing related?)
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
CBC is reporting the fall originating at belly good ledge.
http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-c ... death.html
Unroped and wet from the rains?
http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/british-c ... death.html
Unroped and wet from the rains?
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Tue Apr 19, 2011 9:35 am
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
No way that it would still be wet. Silly to be unroped. Any experienced climbers would know better than to go across unroped, but it's too exposed for a newer climber to think that it would be a good idea. Maybe it was their first time and they thought it was a walk after the first narrow bit? Slipped on some loose stuff over towards Millennium Falcon?
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
Experienced climbers never solo?NateDoggOG wrote: Any experienced climbers would know better than to go across unroped,
-
- Senior Member
- Posts: 236
- Joined: Tue Apr 19, 2011 9:35 am
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
Just hypothesizing about the details. Was it a climber or a lost hiker? Coming off of Bellygood sounds like a climber. For it to be a hiker, they would either have to be really lost, or know exactly where they are going. If they knew where they were going, then chances are they would know what they were getting into on Bellygood.
Was the person alone, or did they have a partner? If they were climbing, then there is probably a 99% chance that they were with someone else. If that's the case, then the chances of both people feeling comfortable going across the narrow bit unroped are cut in half. Besides, if they did come up the Grand, the narrow bit is within spitting distance of the belay atop the Sail Flake. It just seems strange that they might solo across when they can simul it which is just as quick and rather safer.
Don't mind me though, I'm just playing detective. I don't know anything.
Was the person alone, or did they have a partner? If they were climbing, then there is probably a 99% chance that they were with someone else. If that's the case, then the chances of both people feeling comfortable going across the narrow bit unroped are cut in half. Besides, if they did come up the Grand, the narrow bit is within spitting distance of the belay atop the Sail Flake. It just seems strange that they might solo across when they can simul it which is just as quick and rather safer.
Don't mind me though, I'm just playing detective. I don't know anything.
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
This is a truly unfortunate event.
I can't help but wonder though...
People are still debating hiker vs climber - was she wearing a harness or any other climbing-related equipment? Not from what I've heard. That makes her a hiker, no? Not to mention that no partners have come forward (unless fowl play is a factor and she was pushed off Bellygood), which would be a second key indicator, other than the lack of climbing gear on her body.
Those who have been on Bellygood would know that it would be fairly difficult to find, and 99% of "hikers" that would be up there would stop in their tracks at the last thin section where the exposed roots are (starting onto Bellygood from the right).
Sure there are always people around when you get to the last descent rope on the Backside trail, but people just look in awe and keep going, trying to catch their breaths. For the most part, they couldn't be bothered to explore up that way knowing it's a "climbers" trail.
I'm thinking she got lost somewhere in the vicinity of where the Backside trail splits left and goes to The Penthouse/Shelter area, probably to go pee or something, and got a little too close to the edge..... ..................
I can't help but wonder though...
People are still debating hiker vs climber - was she wearing a harness or any other climbing-related equipment? Not from what I've heard. That makes her a hiker, no? Not to mention that no partners have come forward (unless fowl play is a factor and she was pushed off Bellygood), which would be a second key indicator, other than the lack of climbing gear on her body.
Those who have been on Bellygood would know that it would be fairly difficult to find, and 99% of "hikers" that would be up there would stop in their tracks at the last thin section where the exposed roots are (starting onto Bellygood from the right).
Sure there are always people around when you get to the last descent rope on the Backside trail, but people just look in awe and keep going, trying to catch their breaths. For the most part, they couldn't be bothered to explore up that way knowing it's a "climbers" trail.
I'm thinking she got lost somewhere in the vicinity of where the Backside trail splits left and goes to The Penthouse/Shelter area, probably to go pee or something, and got a little too close to the edge..... ..................
- Optimally-Primed
- Senior Member
- Posts: 350
- Joined: Wed Oct 18, 2006 10:04 am
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
Super sad...
Just to toss out another tidbit that may be relevant.
The top of the Upper Black Dyke is directly above the area where she apparently landed. Descending from the first summit, it's really easy to wander over there if you miss a left turn. That said, basic care (even for hikers) keeps the top of the UBD a safe place to have a look over the edge. It would have taken more than a minor slip to go over from there.
Just to toss out another tidbit that may be relevant.
The top of the Upper Black Dyke is directly above the area where she apparently landed. Descending from the first summit, it's really easy to wander over there if you miss a left turn. That said, basic care (even for hikers) keeps the top of the UBD a safe place to have a look over the edge. It would have taken more than a minor slip to go over from there.
- jonny2vests
- Full Member
- Posts: 168
- Joined: Mon May 28, 2012 7:38 am
- Location: Vancouver & Sheffield
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
CBC said SAR reported she fell from Bellygood.Optimally-Primed wrote:Super sad...
Just to toss out another tidbit that may be relevant.
The top of the Upper Black Dyke is directly above the area where she apparently landed. Descending from the first summit, it's really easy to wander over there if you miss a left turn. That said, basic care (even for hikers) keeps the top of the UBD a safe place to have a look over the edge. It would have taken more than a minor slip to go over from there.
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
jonny2vests wrote:CBC said SAR reported she fell from Bellygood.
All the latest info tells us that the exact location is still unknown. SAR probably meant the "vicinity of Bellygood." How could they tell where she feel from without witness verification!?CBC News wrote:Earlier reports from search and rescue officials said the woman fell from an area known as Bellygood Ledge on the Grand Wall, which has a drop of about 500 metres.
- jonny2vests
- Full Member
- Posts: 168
- Joined: Mon May 28, 2012 7:38 am
- Location: Vancouver & Sheffield
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
Ok, I see your logic but it seems odd they would name Bellygood without cause.
-
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Tue Aug 06, 2013 1:28 pm
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
fwiw, i crossed Bellygood a few hours before the woman fell- it was pretty dry, no more sketchy than it usually feels.
the only climbing party behind us was a pair of men climbing the Grand Wall- we didnt see any other parties that would have been on Bellygood, and given the temperature forecast, it seems unlikely that anyone would have hiked up to climb in the afternoon.
super sad to hear about it- between that and the rockfall, it was a pretty crazy day on the Chief- weird that we did the Grand and missed all of it.
the only climbing party behind us was a pair of men climbing the Grand Wall- we didnt see any other parties that would have been on Bellygood, and given the temperature forecast, it seems unlikely that anyone would have hiked up to climb in the afternoon.
super sad to hear about it- between that and the rockfall, it was a pretty crazy day on the Chief- weird that we did the Grand and missed all of it.
Re: BCAS reports a climber has fallen from the Chief
Care to elaborate on the rock fall? I haven't heard about this.John Wilder wrote:super sad to hear about it- between that and the rockfall, it was a pretty crazy day on the Chief- weird that we did the Grand and missed all of it.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 78 guests